As previously discussed, for the majority of my post-WW1 wargaming I like rulesets where the player controls a company or so of infantry with perhaps a few vehicles or heavy weapons in support.
My various "armies" are organized and based for the ruleset FiveCore Company Command (Note: I noticed that the Company Command rules are no longer available on the Nordic Weasel Wargame Vault page...odd). The basic maneuver element is a single base representing a squad of infantry or a heavy weapons attachment or a vehicle.
The Company Command rules are good and I enjoy them every time I play them. They are easy to learn and generally reward good tactics. I like how they simply handle different attachments and weapons and the use of kill and shock dice. More recent updates even include options to address differences in troop quality and leadership. As I've previously discussed here and here, they are simple and robust enough to handle some modifications to add period flavor. Even so, sometimes I feel like I would like a bit more or perhaps a something a bit different.
Two rulesets that I'm looking to kick the proverbial tires on are Hail of Fire and SNAFU. I think both could be easily used as-is or easily modified to handle everything from the Spanish Civil War to Falklands. Both seem simple, quickplay and clock in around a dozen pages of rules (with plenty of additional ratings and organization charts for different combatants and vehicles for WW2).
I've owned HoF for several years and like the concepts, especially in regards to how the effects of shooting are handled. Essentially, if a target receives successful fire and they accrue hits. The players don't know the effect of those hits until the target based that was hit tries to do something. When the target base that took hits tries to do something, the controlling player rolls for the result of each hit and this could range from no effect to suppression to destruction. This creates a fog of war where you don't know how much fire you have to lay down on an opponent to eliminate them.
The other option I'm looking at is SNAFU, a ruleset that came to my attention from a LittleWarsTV post. I watched a few demo videos of games and it seems like it draws some of it's key concepts from the classic Crossfire WW2 rules. There is no limitations on movement distances, however your opponent can use initiative points to interrupt your movement with reactive fire if he has line of sight. What's interesting is that the ranges on weapons seem a bit compact (and the rules explain the rationale behind this). I ordered a print copy from Amazon and they seem pretty straightforward and simple. I will have to give them a go.
Ideally, I'd like to try a single scenario out with each of the above rulesets and see how it plays out with each. Who knows if that will ever happen but I like the idea...



No comments:
Post a Comment